Top 10 Reforming Popes Who Changed the Course of the Church

Table of content

In every age, God has raised up shepherds for His flock; these ten reforming popes stand as monuments to the Holy Spirit’s power to renew the Church, calling us all back to Christ’s original mission.

Dear friends, as we look across the panorama of two millennia of Church history, we see not a static institution, but a living body, ever in need of the Holy Spirit’s cleansing fire. The Church, like each one of us, is simultaneously holy and in need of purification. This is the beautiful, yet sometimes painful, reality of our earthly pilgrimage.

Our faith tells us that Christ is the Head of the Church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it (Matthew 16:18). Yet, as the Church journeys through time, its human members—even its leaders—can lose sight of the Gospel’s radical demands. When this happens, God, in His profound mercy, sends a spark—often in the form of a humble, yet uncompromising, leader who reminds the faithful that true power lies not in worldly authority, but in sacrificial service and adherence to the Truth.

This journey through the lives of the ten most reforming popes is not merely a history lesson. It is a spiritual exercise. It is an exploration of how the prophetic voice, guided by the Spirit, can cut through complacency, challenge corruption, and redirect the entire Body of Christ back toward its source: Jesus Christ, the ultimate Shepherd and Bishop of our souls. Each of these pontiffs teaches us that personal holiness is the only true foundation for institutional renewal, offering a timeless model for renewal in our own lives, families, and communities.

Table of The Top 10 Reforming Popes Who Changed the Course of the Church

Rank	Pope	Reign (Approx.)	Key Reform Area
10	Pope Paul III (Alessandro Farnese)	1534–1549	Initiated the Catholic Counter-Reformation (Council of Trent).
9	Pope St. Leo the Great	440–461	Defense of orthodoxy against heresies; asserted Petrine primacy.
8	Pope St. Pius X	1903–1914	Liturgical renewal; fight against Modernism; encouragement of frequent Communion.
7	Pope St. Paul VI	1963–1978	Guided the implementation of the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II).
6	Pope St. John XXIII	1958–1963	Convoked the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II); Aggiornamento.
5	Pope St. Gregory I (the Great)	590–604	Reorganization of Church administration, liturgy (Gregorian Chant), and missionary work.
4	Pope St. John Paul II	1978–2005	Global evangelization; revision of Canon Law; New Catechism; moral theology.
3	Pope St. Gregory VII (Hildebrand)	1073–1085	The Gregorian Reform; fought simony and clerical marriage; asserted papal authority over secular powers.
2	Pope Innocent III	1198–1216	Fourth Lateran Council (1215); strengthened moral and doctrinal discipline; defined transubstantiation.
1	Pope St. Leo IX (Bruno of Eguisheim-Dagsburg)	1049–1054	The beginning of the great papal reforms; traveled extensively to combat moral abuses and simony.

Top 10. Pope Paul III (Alessandro Farnese) — The Convener of Counsel

The Scene (Context): Pope Paul III inherited a Church fractured by the Protestant Reformation, a crisis of unprecedented proportions that shook the foundations of Europe. He was an elderly man, a product of Renaissance luxury, yet he possessed the foresight and humility to understand that the crisis required not merely political maneuvering, but deep, spiritual introspection. His papacy is defined by one colossal, painful, and necessary act: the convocation of the Council of Trent in 1545. It was a call to prayer, debate, and disciplinary reform that would redefine Catholicism for centuries.

The Theology (Meaning): In convening Trent, Paul III embraced the painful truth of Christ’s words: “By their fruits you will know them” (Matthew 7:20). He realized that the Church’s witness had been tarnished by human failings, particularly the corrupt practices of simony (buying/selling spiritual offices). The Council of Trent, under his guidance, clarified fundamental doctrines like Scripture and Tradition, justification, and the nature of the Sacraments, ensuring that Catholic truth would not be washed away by the tides of dissent. This was not a change of doctrine, but a profound, Spirit-led restatement and reform of discipline.

The Application (Pastoral Care): Paul III’s legacy reminds us that facing uncomfortable truths is the first step toward spiritual growth. When our own lives feel fragmented or compromised, we must, like the Church in his era, pause, pray, and return to the foundational truths of our faith. His work assures us that God provides the grace for renewal, even when the path is long and contentious. It takes courage to reform ourselves, just as it took courage for him to initiate the Counter-Reformation. His call to the Council is a perpetual call to self-examination for all of us at Christian Way.

Spiritual Highlights:

He formally approved the Society of Jesus (Jesuits), a crucial engine of the Counter-Reformation.
The Council of Trent lasted eighteen years and was the Church’s definitive response to the Reformation.
Scripture Connection: “Therefore, having this ministry by the mercy of God, we do not lose heart.” (2 Corinthians 4:1)

Top 9. Pope St. Leo the Great — The Defender of the City and the Creed

The Scene (Context): St. Leo I reigned during a time when the Roman Empire in the West was collapsing under the weight of barbarian invasions. The year 452 saw him personally confront Attila the Hun at the gates of Rome, persuading the formidable leader to turn back—an act that cemented the Papacy’s role as a moral and temporal power in a world without order. He was a brilliant theologian and an equally gifted administrator, ensuring the Petrine Office survived the chaos of the age.

The Theology (Meaning): Leo’s primary theological contribution was the assertion of the doctrine of the hypostatic union—that Christ is one Person with two natures, fully God and fully Man. His famous Tome, read at the Council of Chalcedon in 451, became the definitive statement against Monophysitism. His reform was one of truth: preserving the integrity of the Incarnation, which is the cornerstone of our salvation. He argued that the Pope, as the successor of Peter, holds a special office of teaching, guiding, and correcting the universal Church, a reform that shaped the Papacy’s authority for all time.

The Application (Pastoral Care): For us, St. Leo represents the steadfastness needed to hold fast to the truth when everything around us seems to be falling apart. Whether we face personal calamity or cultural confusion, the foundation remains the Incarnation—God’s commitment to humanity. His courage in facing Attila reminds us that faith is not passive; it is an active defense of the vulnerable and a bold witness to the Gospel in the face of spiritual or earthly threats. We are called to be Leo-like—brave and theologically clear.

Spiritual Highlights:

His Tome established the orthodox Christological teaching at the Council of Chalcedon.
He is one of only two popes traditionally called “the Great” (the other being Gregory I).
Scripture Connection: “The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me to proclaim good news to the poor.” (Luke 4:18)

Top 8. Pope St. Pius X — The Pope of the Eucharist

The Scene (Context): Reigning at the cusp of the 20th century, Pope Pius X was a man of humble, peasant origins who ascended to the Chair of Peter with a clear, singular focus: “To restore all things in Christ” (Instaurare Omnia in Christo). His reform was intensely pastoral, addressing both modern theological errors and practical liturgical life. He was known for his personal austerity and gentle demeanor, yet he acted decisively to protect the faith from internal theological threats.

The Theology (Meaning): Pius X understood that the lifeblood of the Church flowed from the altar. His most enduring reforms centered on the Eucharist. He radically lowered the age for children’s First Communion, declaring that children should receive the Eucharist as soon as they reach the age of reason, and he strongly encouraged the faithful to receive Communion frequently, even daily. He reformed the liturgy to make it more accessible and understandable, aiming to eliminate the distance between the lay faithful and the sacred mysteries. He fought the theological movement of Modernism, which sought to dissolve Christian truths into purely subjective, evolving religious feeling, defending the objectivity of the deposit of faith.

The Application (Pastoral Care): The pastoral heart of St. Pius X is a powerful model for the modern believer. His emphasis on the Eucharist reminds us that our spiritual strength is found not in self-help or human wisdom, but in the real presence of Christ, the Bread of Life (John 6:35). If we feel our faith is lukewarm, his reform challenges us: draw closer to the source of grace! His reform is a call to deep, personal, and frequent communion with the Lord, which is the truest form of Christian renewal.

Spiritual Highlights:

His motto, Instaurare Omnia in Christo, means “To restore all things in Christ.”
He encouraged the faithful to receive Holy Communion frequently, reversing earlier practices of rarity.
Scripture Connection: “Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life, and I will raise him up at the last day.” (John 6:54)

Top 7. Pope St. Paul VI (Giovanni Montini) — The Guide of the Council’s Storm

The Scene (Context): Pope Paul VI inherited the immense, unfinished work of his predecessor, St. John XXIII—the Second Vatican Council. His was the daunting task of both concluding the Council and then implementing its sweeping vision across the global Church, a process that proved profoundly tumultuous. He was a complex, intellectual, and sensitive man who bore the heavy burdens of both renewal and confusion. His reign was marked by deep pastoral compassion, as he tirelessly traveled the globe, becoming the first Pope to visit all five continents.

The Theology (Meaning): Paul VI’s great reform was navigating the post-conciliar Church. He promulgated the major Council documents, bringing to fruition the vision of aggiornamento (updating) and ressourcement (returning to the sources). He reformed the liturgy (the Novus Ordo Mass), introduced the first Roman Missal in centuries, and is perhaps most famous for his 1968 encyclical, Humanae Vitae, which reaffirmed the Church’s teaching on life, marriage, and responsible parenthood against immense contemporary pressure. This act of fidelity to truth, despite its unpopularity, was a powerful, prophetic reform of moral teaching.

The Application (Pastoral Care): The life of Paul VI speaks to the difficulty of remaining a faithful witness in a world rushing toward change. His global travels demonstrated that the Church must be a universal shepherd, reaching out to the margins. For the weary believer, his struggles remind us that the path of Christ is often a way of the cross, even for those who lead. We learn from him the necessity of compassionate dialogue combined with uncompromising fidelity to the difficult truths of the Gospel, especially concerning the sanctity of human life and love.

Spiritual Highlights:

He concluded the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II) and began its implementation.
His apostolic exhortation Evangelii Nuntiandi on evangelization is a foundation for modern missionary activity.
Scripture Connection: “And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry…” (Ephesians 4:11–12)

Top 6. Pope St. John XXIII (Angelo Roncalli) — The Pope of Open Windows

The Scene (Context): Pope John XXIII was elected in 1958 at the age of 76, widely viewed as a gentle, transitional, or “caretaker” Pope. Yet, this humble man, with a warm smile and a deep love for humanity, proved to be one of the most revolutionary figures in Church history. Just three months into his papacy, he announced the convocation of the Second Vatican Council (Vatican II) in 1959. It was an unexpected, stunning, and Spirit-inspired move that changed the internal life and external posture of the Church.

The Theology (Meaning): His reform was guided by the concept of aggiornamento—bringing up to date. He did not seek to change the eternal truths of the faith, but to express them in a language that the modern world could understand and appreciate. He opened the windows of the Church to let in the fresh air of the Holy Spirit. His social encyclical, Pacem in Terris (Peace on Earth), was the first papal letter addressed not just to the faithful, but to “all men of good will,” calling for global peace, human rights, and religious freedom—a profound re-framing of the Church’s engagement with the world.

The Application (Pastoral Care): St. John XXIII’s life is a powerful witness that wisdom and divine inspiration can come from the most unexpected places. His gentle confidence in the Spirit reminds us that we should never fear engaging the modern world, nor should we be afraid of necessary, Spirit-led change in our own lives. His willingness to take a radical step (convoking the Council) teaches us that the greatest acts of faith often require a complete reliance on God and a simple, childlike obedience to His call. We must have the courage to open the “windows” of our own hearts to allow Christ’s light to shine out.

Spiritual Highlights:

He convened the Second Vatican Council (1962–1965), one of the most significant events of the 20th century.
His social encyclical, Pacem in Terris, was an appeal for global peace and universal human rights.
Scripture Connection: “Do not extinguish the Spirit.” (1 Thessalonians 5:19)

Top 5. Pope St. Gregory I (the Great) — The Servant of the Servants of God

The Scene (Context): Born into a wealthy Roman family, St. Gregory I was Prefect of Rome—the highest civil post—before giving up his riches to become a monk. Thrust onto the papal throne in 590 by popular acclamation during a time of famine, plague, and Lombard invasion, he was forced to step into the void of collapsing civil authority. He saw himself primarily as a servant, famously adopting the title servus servorum Dei (Servant of the Servants of God), a title popes still use today.

The Theology (Meaning): Gregory’s reform was essentially practical, organizational, and liturgical. He completely reorganized the Church’s administration and finances, using the Church’s wealth (the Patrimony of St. Peter) to feed the poor, ransom captives, and manage the city of Rome, acting as a true shepherd to the afflicted. His great liturgical reform involved the codification and spread of the plainsong chants that bear his name, Gregorian Chant, which brought unity and spiritual depth to the Roman liturgy. Moreover, he spurred missionary activity, famously sending St. Augustine of Canterbury to evangelize the Angles and Saxons in Britain, planting the seeds of faith for a new millennium.

The Application (Pastoral Care): Gregory the Great shows us the perfect integration of spirituality and service. His decision to put civil administration aside for monastic life, and then to use that administrative brilliance for the good of the poor, demonstrates that all our talents must be consecrated to Christ’s service. His title reminds us that true leadership is always characterized by humility and self-giving love. If we wish to be great in the Kingdom, we must be servants to all (Mark 10:43–45).

Spiritual Highlights:

He famously adopted the title servus servorum Dei (Servant of the Servants of God).
He is credited with the codification and widespread use of the liturgical music known as Gregorian Chant.
Scripture Connection: “Just as the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.” (Matthew 20:28)

Top 4. Pope St. John Paul II (Karol Wojtyła) — The Evangelist of the Modern Age

The Scene (Context): Elected in 1978, the Polish Pope John Paul II began the third-longest pontificate in history, ushering in a new era of global engagement. He survived World War II, Communism, and an assassination attempt, making him a powerful, moral witness to the resilience of the Christian faith. His reform was a magnificent, comprehensive effort to prepare the Church for the Third Millennium, focusing on anthropology and evangelization.

The Theology (Meaning): John Paul II’s reform was arguably the most sweeping since Trent. He promulgated the new Code of Canon Law (1983) and oversaw the publication of the universally accessible Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992), bringing clarity and unity of teaching after the Council. Theologically, his primary contributions were his Theology of the Body—a profound teaching on human love, sexuality, and God’s design—and his call for a New Evangelization, urging all Christians to share the Gospel with “new ardor, new methods, and new expressions.” Politically, his support for freedom played a crucial role in the peaceful dissolution of Communist regimes in Eastern Europe, demonstrating the power of spiritual conviction over political force.

The Application (Pastoral Care): St. John Paul II’s tireless traveling and his deep connection with youth (exemplified by the World Youth Days) challenges us to make our faith visible and active. His life urges us not to fear the future but to boldly proclaim Christ in every corner of the world, whether that corner is a foreign country or our own workplace. His famous opening words, “Be not afraid!” echo Christ’s constant reassurance to us, reminding us that in Christ, we find the strength to transform culture.

Spiritual Highlights:

He implemented the revised Code of Canon Law and the modern Catechism of the Catholic Church.
His teachings on the Theology of the Body remain a major contribution to Christian anthropology.
Scripture Connection: “Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” (Matthew 28:19)

Top 3. Pope St. Gregory VII (Hildebrand) — The Crusader for Clerical Integrity

The Scene (Context): Reigning in the mid-11th century, Pope Gregory VII (originally Hildebrand) faced a Church crippled by its dependence on secular rulers. Emperors and kings routinely appointed bishops, abbots, and even popes (a practice called lay investiture), leading to widespread corruption, including the buying and selling of Church offices (simony) and unchaste behavior among the clergy. The spiritual integrity of the Church was at stake, threatened by the seductive allure of wealth and power.

The Theology (Meaning): Gregory VII’s reform, known as the Gregorian Reform, was a decisive, radical move to secure the spiritual independence and purity of the clergy. He issued the Dictatus Papae (27 statements on papal power), which radically asserted the Pope’s authority to depose emperors and to have sole authority in ecclesiastical appointments, a reform that shook the foundations of the medieval world. Furthermore, he vigorously enforced clerical celibacy, believing that only a detached, spiritually focused clergy could truly shepherd the flock. His reform was not about political power for its own sake, but about freeing the Church to be the spiritual authority Christ intended.

The Application (Pastoral Care): Gregory VII’s struggle, which included his famous conflict with Emperor Henry IV, reminds the modern believer of the constant spiritual battle between the values of the world and the values of the Kingdom. His uncompromising stance against simony is a lesson for us: we must guard against letting worldly ambition, comfort, or financial gain corrupt our spiritual mission. His life calls us to maintain the integrity of our own vocation, ensuring that our service to Christ is pure, unbought, and driven solely by the love of God.

Spiritual Highlights:

He decisively fought the practices of lay investiture and simony to secure the Church’s independence.
The Gregorian Reform radically reformed clerical discipline, enforcing celibacy.
Scripture Connection: “You were bought with a price; do not become slaves of men.” (1 Corinthians 7:23)

Top 2. Pope Innocent III (Lotario dei Conti di Segni) — The Vicar of Christ in the World

The Scene (Context): Pope Innocent III, who reigned from 1198 to 1216, is often considered the most powerful of the medieval popes, both spiritually and politically. He was a brilliant lawyer and theologian who came to power at a time when the Church was dominant but needed deep, internal cleaning. He understood that spiritual renewal required institutional clarity and doctrinal precision. He patronized the burgeoning mendicant orders, famously approving the Rule of St. Francis of Assisi and St. Dominic, recognizing their potential to reform the Church from the grassroots.

The Theology (Meaning): Innocent III’s greatest act of reform was the convocation of the Fourth Lateran Council in 1215, a monumental event that reformed almost every aspect of Church life. The Council established the doctrine of Transubstantiation—the theological explanation of how the bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Christ—as official teaching. Furthermore, it required the faithful to confess their sins and receive the Eucharist at least once a year (The Easter Duty), ensuring a basic level of sacramental life. This Council was a profound reform of discipline, bringing moral and sacramental structure to the entire Christian populace, ensuring that no one could claim to be a Christian without adhering to the core practices of the faith.

The Application (Pastoral Care): Innocent III’s emphasis on confession and the Eucharist reminds us of the twin pillars of the Christian life: reconciliation and nourishment. The annual Easter Duty, while a disciplinary measure, serves as a loving check on our souls, preventing spiritual drift. We must understand, as he did, that without frequent return to Christ’s grace (Confession) and communion with His presence (Eucharist), our spiritual vitality will wither. His work is a perpetual invitation to sacramental renewal.

Spiritual Highlights:

He convened the Fourth Lateran Council, which defined the doctrine of Transubstantiation.
He mandated the “Easter Duty” (Confession and Communion at least once a year).
Scripture Connection: “Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you.” (John 6:53)

Top 1. Pope St. Leo IX (Bruno of Eguisheim-Dagsburg) — The Traveler Against Corruption

The Scene (Context): Pope St. Leo IX, reigning from 1049–1054, is the true catalyst for the radical, transformative Gregorian Reforms that followed. Before him, the Papacy had been a local office, often controlled by Roman aristocratic families. Leo IX, a German bishop appointed by the Emperor, traveled extensively, which was highly unusual for a Pope. He held synods across Europe—in Reims, Mainz, and Vercelli—personally confronting bishops who were guilty of simony (buying their office) or lacked chastity. His physical presence and moral courage brought the highest papal authority to bear directly on local corruption.

The Theology (Meaning): Leo IX’s reform was one of presence and purity. He understood that the Church’s authority would only be respected if its leaders were morally impeccable. By traveling and personally deposing corrupt clergy, he effectively elevated the moral standard required for the spiritual office, reinforcing the essential truth that the power of the priesthood is rooted in Christ, not in local political patronage or personal wealth. His action of personally confronting abuses was the necessary prelude to the later, more legalistic reforms. Tragically, his papacy also saw the beginning of the Great Schism of 1054 with the Eastern Orthodox Church, an agonizing reminder that even in reform, human division remains a sorrowful reality.

The Application (Pastoral Care): As the foremost of the reforming popes, St. Leo IX teaches us the profound importance of visible witness. He refused to be an armchair shepherd; he walked among the flock, demanding integrity. For us, this means that our faith cannot be compartmentalized; it must be brought into every sphere of our life, personally challenging the moral compromises that we see in our homes, workplaces, or communities. His bold action reminds us that the spiritual purity of our own soul is the most important field of battle.

Spiritual Highlights:

He was the first Pope to travel extensively throughout Europe to enforce moral and disciplinary reforms.
He actively sought out and deposed bishops guilty of simony and immorality.
Scripture Connection: “You are the salt of the earth, but if salt has lost its taste, how can its saltiness be restored?” (Matthew 5:13)

Reflect and Pray: The Timeless Call to Renewal

The lives of these ten reforming popes are not simply chapters in a history book; they are a living commentary on the promise of the Holy Spirit. They teach us that God never abandons His Church, but continually calls it—and us—to a deeper conversion. Whenever we see darkness, whenever we feel the urge to compromise our principles for comfort or status, we must look to these shepherds and remember that true authority comes from integrity, humility, and uncompromising devotion to the truth of Christ. May their example inspire us all to be agents of renewal in our own corner of the vineyard.

— Fr. John Matthew, for Christian Way